Are You Really Catholic?

Do Catholics even know what it even means to be Catholic anymore? Do we even know what we believe in, or is it all just a personal opinion?  I say this because after watching several days worth of the Democratic National Convention, there seems to be a lot of very confused Catholics in high ranking positions, making the general public even more confused about Catholicism.

The best example of this had to be Caroline Kennedy, who began her speech with this line:

“As a Catholic woman, I take reproductive health seriously, and today, it is under attack. This year alone, more than a dozen states have passed more than 40 restrictions on women’s access to reproductive health care. That’s not the kind of future I want for my daughters or your daughters. Now isn’t the time to roll back the rights we were winning when my father was president. Now is the time to move this country forward.”

To anyone watching, one would think that Catholics support abortion & contraception!

After hearing the DNC I am inclined to agree with the Pope who came out last month and said that it would be better for people – who don’t believe in certain aspects of the faith, such as matters concerning life and family  – to leave.

Finally, Jesus knew that even among the twelve apostles there was one that did not believe: Judas. Judas could have left, as many of the disciples did; indeed, he would have left if he were honest. Instead he remained with Jesus. He did not remain because of faith, or because of love, but with the secret intention of taking vengeance on the Master. Why? Because Judas felt betrayed by Jesus, and decided that he in turn would betray Him. Judas was a Zealot, and wanted a triumphant Messiah, who would lead a revolt against the Romans. Jesus had disappointed those expectations. The problem is that Judas did not go away, and his most serious fault was falsehood, which is the mark of the devil. This is why Jesus said to the Twelve: “One of you is a devil” (John 6.70). We pray to the Virgin Mary, help us to believe in Jesus, as St. Peter did, and to always be sincere with Him and with all people.

I guess I don’t understand why people who disagree so strongly with the Church stay. If they really wanted the Church to change how does belonging to it further their cause?  Do they think that if they get enough voices that the Church will change? Do they honestly believe the Church is a democracy?

Or perhaps our educators are not doing a good enough job of telling people that these things will never change, that the Church is not a democracy and it cannot change what Jesus taught.  For example, we will never see women priests or call abortion anything but “intrinsically evil”.  Perhaps we will lose people with this approach but, at least they will have to think long and hard about what they believe and what the Church teaches. Can they be like Peter and have faith and believe, even though they may not yet understand? Like the Pope says when he quotes St. Augustine:

“He does not say we have understood and then we believed, but we believed and then we understood. We have believed in order to be able to understand; if, in fact, we wanted to understand before believing, we would not be able either to understand or to believe.”

To use a sports and coaching analogy:  if the whole team isn’t on the same page their can be no victory.  If the coach is telling the team to play zone defence and a couple players think the coach is wrong and play man, what will the outcome be? Not a good  outcome for anyone.  It would be better for all players and coaches involved for those players to leave and form their own team.  This does not mean we are uncharitable towards these people, but at least we hold them accountable because they are being hypocritical. We wish, very much, that they could believe, that they would have a true conversion of heart, but we have to respect their free will to choose.

I know it is not that easy, but I think it’s better than the confusion that seems to be prevalent in Catholics today.  At least it will give me more class time to focus on why the Church believes this, rather than spending the bulk of my time correcting the confusion of what Catholics “actually” believe.

This entry was posted in Apologetics, Catholic, politics, Religious Ed, Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to Are You Really Catholic?

  1. I wonder the same thing. How can someone say they’re Catholic when they clearly don’t follow the teachings of Holy Mother Church? Maybe, referencing St. Augustine, they don’t really believe, or their is formation is so bad, they believe wrongly. I don’t get it. Great post!


  2. This is a great post. As a newly formed Young Adult Ministry, we try to find passionate faithful people that provide insightful information about what the church teaches. Would we be able to mention you and repost this on our blog?


  3. Reblogged this on "The one will LIFT up his companion." and commented:
    Today we have a guest blogger. She is a fellow young adult from Canada. She teaches at a Catholic High School. She is passionate about her faith and blogs about what she has learned. She said, “The more I learn the more I realize there is so much more to Catholicism and even a lifetime won’t be enough to study it all.”
    Here is one of her recent post:


  4. BrendaBuzz says:

    I think many people who fit this category, especially Cradle Catholics, don’t even view their objections as cause to leave the church, because they don’t fully grasp how grave the matters are- especially the matter of obedience. They don’t view their defiance as contradictory to the Catholic denomination in particular, due to lack of a true understanding of the teachings, history etc(especially dogma, which is divine inspired/revealed and thus not arguable….enter abortion, confession, marriage) There is a sentiment these people have of human fallibility in the teachings, coupled with the notion that the church is outdated and Jesus understands that and thus them. The church is viewed as stagnant and outdated, VS unchanging and divinely ordered and instructed. Additionally, the Cradle portion of these Catholics means their religious identity is also largely cultural and plays a large role in their identity. It’s like being Jewish because your mother is Jewish…but not really living out the Judaic laws/guidelines although you cherish the traditions/food etc.
    I was one of those people until recently. I did NOT believe in the authority of the Pope, did not really agree with confession as mandatory, and I strongly opposed the strict Church demands on abortion, contraception and divorce. I am learning about the rich history of the church, the dogma assertions and constant demand for obedience/humility in Bible, I am blown away. The church has never changed its teachings on values, because they have received the instruction from divine revelation and divine guidance of leaders who once selected, receive grace and guidance. It’s amazing. It requires obedience, humility, FAITH, but once a person gets over their idea of morality or “what God would want” and listens to the truth, it is amazing. Also, I am a huge Virgin Mary devotee and find it interesting that Vatican approved Marian apparitions and the corresponding messages have NEVER contradicted the fundamental Catholic Church teachings( I advise all Catholics to look up approved Marian Apparitions because the stories, miracles and her messages help strengthen what sometimes feels like a tough battle of faith in a secular, increasingly anti-God world).
    I will say this though… despite my obvious contradictions…I never felt like I was not Catholic. I still don’t think I was NOT Catholic, if anything I was a non compliant Catholic…lost, strayed and having good intentions but just misguided ones. A victim of the haughty energy produced by the intellectual yet ignorant generation of our times. I don’t think the answer is to tell people to leave the church because some people are unknowingly arrogant/haughty, ignorant, unaware and also placing their compassion in a misguided way. They need to be educated and then if they still reject teachings..that’s another story. I did dabble in other Protestant churches while still attending mass. May sound upsetting to some people but I am 100% certain that my little connection to my faith was what saved me and allowed me to return. I totally respect the notion that you should leave the church if you will not even stand by its teachings…but I think energy should first be placed in reaching out and seeing the underlying “why”.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s